?>

Freedom Convoy Protest: Is Crypto Really “Free” from Government Control?

2.2 k views
Freedom Convoy Protest Is Cryptocurrency Really Free from Government Control

Freedom is a word synonymous with crypto. There is freedom from traditional finance systems, freedom from government control, and of course, financial freedom.

So it made sense that when Canadian Freedom Convoy protesters needed an alternative platform to receive donations, they chose crypto. At least, it aligned with what the protesters stood for literally and figuratively. However, despite what should have been a smart move, the government exerted its influence on protestors’ holdings, raising questions on how free crypto really is.

Freedom Convoy and Bitcoin: The Backstory

The Group, their Agitations

On January 15, the Canadian government mandated truckers who used the US-Canada border to present proof of vaccination to cross the border. A week later, the US government gave a similar mandate. 

On Friday, January 28, Ottawa, Canada’s capital city, came under siege. A convoy of trucks blockaded streets. And what started with a few hundred protesters snowballed into an agitation involving about 8,000 people. These protesters pestered citizens and forced business closures. And for more than two weeks, this was the reality of Ottawa as protesters demanded a reversal of the Covid-19 vaccine mandate. 

In addition to revoking the mandate, protesters demanded an end to every Covid-19 restriction in Canada or the resignation of Justin Trudeau, the country’s prime minister. Although similar protests sparked off in New York, Wellington, and Paris, it was Ottawa’s protest that attracted international attention — because of its political undertone.

The Demonstration, the Divide, and the Donations

What started as a demonstration against Covid-19 restrictions quickly morphed into a clash of political ideologies. Behind the scene were the financiers who sustained the protest with sizeable donations. Leaked data from GiveSendGo, a Christian crowdfunding platform, revealed that donors also had connections with activism against American democracy and the Black Lives Matter movement. 

The Freedom Convoy protest received donations through GoFundMe and GiveSendGo and raised up to $7.9 million and $9.2 million respectively. But days later, GoFundMe paused donations to the protest. In their official statement, GoFundMe said: 

[we have] evidence from law enforcement that the previously peaceful demonstration has become an occupation, with police reports of violence and other unlawful activity.” 

They also announced that they would refund the contributions of all donors. About a week later, Toronto-Dominion Bank froze $1.1 million transferred from GiveSendGo to individual accounts. The bank had received an order from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau invoked the Emergency Act

Even though it seemed the government went for the jugular, the truckers sustained momentum. With their fundings intercepted, they had to turn to a boundless, decentralized mode of funding.

Enter Bitcoin — and other cryptos

Although Bitcoin’s safe-haven function during economic turmoil is still a debated topic, it has not failed as a safe haven during protests. From the #EndSARS protest in Nigeria to the pro-democracy movement in Thailand, Bitcoin has been a sanctuary for demonstrators to escape government-imposed financial restrictions. And the Freedom Convoy protest was no exception. 

Supporters of the protest started donating Bitcoins towards the protest. Bitcoin donations surpassed the 21-Bitcoin goal set by the truckers as 5,511 donors raised over 22 Bitcoins worth about $932,000. 20% of the donations were held in a hardware wallet for meeting the immediate needs (food, accommodation, legal aid) of the truckers. The remaining 80% went to a multisig wallet for collaborative custody. 

But the Canadian government wasn’t ready to give up yet. In an unprecedented move, crypto assets tied to over 120 wallets connected to the protests were frozen by the government. The police ordered regulated financial firms to stop processing transactions from these wallets. The sanctioned wallet addresses were tied to Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH), Cardano (ADA), Ethereum Classic (ETC), Litecoin (LTC), and Monero (XMR).

These assets were frozen after the Ontario Superior Court of Justice signed a Mareva Injunction. According to Coindesk, this injunction freezes an individual’s assets to prevent them from being spent, moved or hidden. This means that the government can order the freezing of assets in any financial institution holding them — including crypto firms in this case. Digital assets firms mentioned in the injunction include Binance Smart Chain, Bull Bitcoin, PancakeSwap, TallyCoin, Nunchuk, Bylls, Satoshi Portal, Shakepay, and BitBuy.

The freezing of these digital assets begs the question: Can cryptocurrencies actually escape governmental control? 

Crypto’s Achilles Heel in the Mareva Injunction

A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution.” – Satoshi

This was the opening statement in the famous Bitcoin whitepaper.  Satoshi Nakamoto’s aim was to create an autonomous and decentralized financial system where traditional financial institutions do not act as a bridge. However, governments have continued to clamor for the regulation of cryptocurrencies and other digital assets. The crypto community, on the other hand, has been unfazed by the moves of governments to halt or control crypto transactions. At least, there is the popular belief that crypto transactions are untraceable. But the dramatic turn of events during the Freedom Convoy protest raises a cause for concern. 

In Canada, crypto companies and exchanges must register with the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC). The institution requires these companies to collect the basic biodata of their users. So with the Mareva Injunction, the government could easily order these companies to identify the protesters on these platforms and freeze their assets. An exchange like Bitbuy willingly complied with the order.

Other exchanges like Kraken were forced to comply as well, despite taking a public opposite stance.

Paradoxical Weakness

Crypto institutions and establishments must be legal to attain traction. To be legal, institutions must register with legally-required bodies. Their compulsory registration with the government means they are subject to its laws and vulnerable to the decree of a centralized system. It is at once a Catch-22: an impossible situation.

If government-regulated crypto platforms can freeze the assets of users, doesn’t this embody an amusing paradox in the crypto space: a decentralized technology run by centralized/political systems? Doesn’t this paradox mock the very reason behind the birth of Bitcoin and other altcoins? Lastly, doesn’t it cede control to the government and institutions of traditional finance?

Affirmative answers to these questions would have far-reaching implications for cryptocurrency; however, there are still positives.

Crypto’s Free Impenetrable Fort

The business model of several crypto firms in Canada made it easy for the Mareva Injunction to take effect. However, for Nunchuk.io, it was a different story. 

Authorities could not freeze crypto assets stored in wallets provided by Nunchuk.io. The company stated the reason for this in their official response to the Mareva Injunction.

Dear the Ontario Superior Court of Justice,” the response began, “Nunchuk is a self-custodial, collaborative-multisig Bitcoin wallet. We are a software provider, not a custodial financial intermediary.”

In other words, Nunchuk only provides a platform for users to host their wallets. It has no repository of users’ details save their email addresses. According to their response, they could neither freeze assets nor stop their transfers to other wallets. Thus, as if meeting an impenetrable fort, Canadian authorities have not been able to seize about 14.6 Bitcoin transferred to 101 unique, unidentified wallets. 

As of March 24th, despite numerous attempts from the authorities to seize more BTC, the assets remain free. This is also due in part to proactive sermons to protesters to ditch centralized exchanges for non-custodial wallets. Jesse Powell, CEO of major crypto exchange Kraken, was one of the loudest voices.

But multisig wallets are not the impenetrable fort per se, rather, their strength lies in the two qualities of crypto they preserve: autonomy and decentralization. In these two, crypto finds its strength and uniqueness. The more reasons why these qualities require preservation vis-a-vis blocking loopholes for control. 

Decentralization is not the Government’s Friend

On March 25th, Coindesk reported that the European Union Parliament was mulling a ban on anonymous crypto transactions. The ban could, in effect, render most non-custodial crypto services in Europe illegal.  The EU’s move also notably comes after the parliament pushed back an initial Anti-PoW draft. However, the proposed ban against anonymous crypto transactions might not be as fortunate.

An anti-anonymous ban had been initially floated in July last year, without much verve. Mairead McGuinness, the EU financial services commissioner, insisted at the time that authorities should subject crypto to the same laws as fiat money.

We shouldn’t have different rules for the financial system. They should apply across digital currencies as well.”

Except that cryptocurrencies actually thrive on the difference. A crypto token is different from its fiat equivalent, both in operation and characteristic. The crypto industry did not achieve traction in the past few years by behaving like fiat money. Perhaps, one could also argue this level of adoption wouldn’t be possible if crypto had been governable under the same centralized laws.

The tenets and prospect of cryptocurrency obviously depend on its decentralization, just as it relies on adoption.  However, should the government manage to clamp or take away its freedom, then crypto would lose part of its meaning.

The Ultimate Dread

Could the government one day explicitly outlaw cryptocurrencies? Most likely not. A ban on crypto, like the Canadian authorities’ desperate crackdown on virtual assets, could have the opposite effect. The government knows this, and popular economist Saifedean Ammous perhaps sums it up just perfectly. 

The way for them [the government] to kill Bitcoin is for them to make the economic incentive to use Bitcoin irrelevant — to make the demand for using Bitcoin go away at the source. They need to offer a technology that is better than Bitcoin — that can obviate the need for Bitcoin. Or, at least, they need to try.” 

Closing Words

Freedom is synonymous with crypto quite alright, but the Freedom Convoy protest showed that this freedom could be threatened. Canada may have succeeded in dismissing the protest with the Mareva Injunction; however, that singular move has sparked up a new conversation: one filled with questions. Could anti-crypto governments exploit crypto’s, Achilles Heel? Does this weak point provide opportunities for indicting crypto fraudsters? If yes, can governmental institutions draw the line between nabbing cybercrime and infringing on the rights of honest crypto users?

Bitcoin coin symbol
Btc
Bitcoin
$62.547
price
red chart
decrease symbol0.84959%
price change
TRADE NOW

Lastly, could crypto ever be truly, really, free?

Previous

EU Legislators May Vote to Ban Anonymous Crypto Payments

Next

WMA: Bitcoin Close to $45,000 and Altcoins Soar

Written by

Daami PK

@Daami

334 posts

PK Daami is a content writer, fiction lover, and AI developer. He writes or has written for outfits like Realm, ChangeNOW, and SatoshiLab’s Invity.

VIEW AUTHOR

More author posts

Turkey to Receive Crypto Aid Following Devastating Earthquakes

In the last 24 hours, several crypto businesses have stepped up with a promise to help Turkey after the nation suffered two ruinous earthquakes. These alongside numerous aftershocks have claimed over 1500 lives across Turkey and Syria. Parts of both regions have crumbled following the disaster meaning, not all the victims have been discovered yet. On Monday, February 6, Turkey's Kahramanmaras Province took a hit from a devastating 7.8 magnitude earthquake. A few hours later, it was followed by another…

Russia’s SberBank to Launch DeFi Platform in May

In a release on Friday, Russian news outlet Interfax shared updates regarding the nation’s largest bank, Sberbank’s forthcoming DeFi platform. Russia’s leading financial entity is reportedly making steady progress as it approaches its project’s launch date. According to Konstantin Klimenko, Product Director of the Blockchain Laboratory of Sberbank, open testing should kick off by March.  SberBank’s DeFi System to Replace its TradFi Systems At the moment, Sberbank’s platform is undergoing private beta testing. However, Klimenko set a tentative deadline for…

Ethereum’s Zhejiang Staking Withdrawal Testnet for Shanghai is Live

At 15:00 UTC on Wednesday, the much-anticipated Zhejiang testnet for staking withdrawal went live on Ethereum’s Beacon chain. Zhejiang will enable the testing of the Ethereum Improvement Proposal (EIP) 4895 which allows for staking withdrawals. This is in preparation for the network’s next major update, the Shanghai hard fork slated to launch sometime in March. Users Can Make Simulated Withdrawals with Zhejiang In a tweet yesterday, DevOps engineer at Ethereum foundation Barnabas Busa gave details about the Zhejiang testnet slated…

Doge Rises Amid Reports of Crypto Support on Twitter

According to a Financial Times report, CEO Elon Musk would like Twitter’s in-progress payment model to incorporate cryptocurrencies. Amid the mooted revelations, Musk’s favorite crypto Dogecoin experienced a notable surge in value. The token hit a daily high but retraced its steps soon after.  Elon Musk became Twitter owner and CEO on the 27th of October last year. Despite still being in the early days of the handover, Twitter has experienced a slew of makeovers in the last few months.…

Cardano’s Dexes to List First ADA-based Stablecoin Djed Next Week

DEXs, MinSwap and MuesliSwap, currently have $30 million and $6.5 million worth of liquidity locked in them respectively   On Thursday, COTI Network, the issuer of the Cardano-backed stablecoin Djed announced its upcoming listing on major DEXs MinSwap and Muesliswap. COTI also added that Shen, its reserve coin, would be on that listing. MuesliSwap to List DJED and SHEN On Thursday afternoon, COTI retweeted the MuesliSwap announcement that revealed the exchange’s plan to list $Djed and $Shen in the coming…

Tesla’s BTC Positions Remained Unchanged in Q4 of 2022

According to a new earning report from automotive manufacturer Tesla, the company did not sell any of its BTC holdings in the fourth quarter of 2022. Amid speculations that the company had traded BTC during the testing bears, CEO Elon Musk revealed it was yet holding on to its BTC stash. Tesla Maintains Holdings After Initial Sell-Off In Q2 of 2022, Tesla opted to sell 75% of all its BTC. The car manufacturer received close to $950M in exchange. Notably,…

Publish your own article

Guest post article. Guaranteed publishing with just a few clicks

START PUBLISHING ADVERTISE WITH US

Browse categories

Explore trending topics in the crypto community right now.

Bitcoin

SEC Greenlights Multiple Bitcoin ETFs, Signaling Major Leap for Cryptocurrency Markets

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has made a landmark decision by approving 11 spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This move represents a significant moment in the cryptocurrency industry, marking a shift towards greater institutional adoption and accessibility for investors. The approved ETFs include products from major firms such as BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust, Grayscale Bitcoin Trust, ARK 21Shares Bitcoin ETF, Bitwise Bitcoin ETP Trust, WisdomTree Bitcoin Fund, Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Trust, VanEck Bitcoin Trust, Invesco Galaxy Bitcoin…

Bitcoin Should be Banned in the United States: Charlie Munger

Berkshire Hathaway’s vice chairman, Charlie Munger, called for a ban on cryptocurrency in the United States on Monday, similar to the one in China.  In an op-ed published with the Wall Street Journal, Munger argued that Bitcoin isn’t a currency, commodity, or security, but simply a form of gambling “ with a nearly 100% edge for the house. As such, the enactment of a federal law should ban such things from happening. Munger cited the Chinese communist party’s ban on…

Tesla’s BTC Positions Remained Unchanged in Q4 of 2022

According to a new earning report from automotive manufacturer Tesla, the company did not sell any of its BTC holdings in the fourth quarter of 2022. Amid speculations that the company had traded BTC during the testing bears, CEO Elon Musk revealed it was yet holding on to its BTC stash. Tesla Maintains Holdings After Initial Sell-Off In Q2 of 2022, Tesla opted to sell 75% of all its BTC. The car manufacturer received close to $950M in exchange. Notably,…

Here’s When Grayscale Debates the SEC in Court on its Bitcoin Spot ETF

The District of Columbia Court of Appeals has marked a date for when Grayscale and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may present oral arguments regarding the approval of a Bitcoin spot ETF.  Each side will present its case at 9:30 am ET on March 7, with the SEC arguing against the product, and Grayscale arguing in favor.  Grayscale VS SEC The court date – revealed in a court order filed on Monday according to CNBC – is much earlier…

MORE ARTICLES

Ethereum

Ethereum’s Zhejiang Staking Withdrawal Testnet for Shanghai is Live

At 15:00 UTC on Wednesday, the much-anticipated Zhejiang testnet for staking withdrawal went live on Ethereum’s Beacon chain. Zhejiang will enable the testing of the Ethereum Improvement Proposal (EIP) 4895 which allows for staking withdrawals. This is in preparation for the network’s next major update, the Shanghai hard fork slated to launch sometime in March. Users Can Make Simulated Withdrawals with Zhejiang In a tweet yesterday, DevOps engineer at Ethereum foundation Barnabas Busa gave details about the Zhejiang testnet slated…

Ethereum Devs Disagree Over Technical Tweak as Shanghai Upgrade Nears

Post-merge Ethereum users have been eagerly awaiting the commencement of the network’s next major upgrade, Shanghai. However, after over 3 months of prep time, it appears the Shanghai rollout isn’t going as smoothly as expected. What Exactly is the Shanghai Upgrade? In September last year, the much-publicized Ethereum Merge also known as the Ethereum 2.0 upgrade went live. Ethereum underwent some significant changes as its consensus mechanism transitioned from proof-of-work to a cost-efficient proof-of-stake system.  However, since the Beacon launch…

FTX Hacker Converts 50k Stolen ETH to BTC

Per a report from blockchain analysis firm Chainalysis, the attacker behind the Nov 11 FTX exploit, is converting the stolen ETH to Bitcoin. There were muted fears the seemingly inexperienced perpetrator could dump all its ETH holdings. On Sunday, the attacker dumped 50k ETH on-chain, with ETH's price dipping by almost 7%.  https://twitter.com/chainalysis/status/1594349583416840199?s=20&t=pgvQHeVytI20eKQ1ls9bxw Hacker Moves 50,000 ETH to New Address Over the past week, the perpetrator had been steadily swapping the cryptocurrencies they had carted off for Ether tokens. This…

Censorship Concerns: 51% of Ethereum Blocks Now OFAC Compliant

According to new data, over half of the blocks on the Ethereum network now reportedly comply with the US Treasury OFAC’s standards. This comes roughly a month after the platform’s monumental merge update. Phasing Out Tornado Cash The Office of Foreign Assets Control is the intelligence and enforcement agency of the US  Treasury Department. Indeed, the OFAC administers and enforces US  financial sanctions. A prime example of this is the recent, highly-publicized ban on crypto mixer Tornado Cash.  According to…

MORE ARTICLES

Trading

How to Leverage Arbitrage Opportunities in Crypto Markets

Cryptocurrency arbitrage has become an increasingly popular investment strategy as the crypto market grows and evolves. Arbitrage involves taking advantage of pricing discrepancies between markets or exchanges to profit.  Investors can leverage profit opportunities by understanding cryptocurrency arbitrage while managing associated risks. In this guide, we'll explore cryptocurrency arbitrage and how it works. A Bitcoin-related example will help us illustrate the concepts of this strategy. What is Arbitrage and How Does it Work in Crypto Markets Crypto arbitrage trading is…

The Different Types of Copy Trading in Crypto

Are you interested in trading cryptocurrencies but feel intimidated by the complexity of the process? Copy trading is a great way to get into crypto without needing to be an experienced trader. With copy trading, investors can benefit from the experience and knowledge of more experienced traders, allowing even beginners to succeed. How does copy trading work, and which tips do you need to know to succeed? In this article, we'll explore all aspects of copy trading in crypto. What…

How to Spot an Unsafe Crypto Exchange

Cryptocurrency exchanges have become increasingly popular as they provide a platform for people to buy and sell digital assets. Unfortunately, not all crypto exchanges are safe or reliable.  With the rise of cybercrime and fraud, you must learn to spot an unsafe crypto exchange before investing your money. This guide will help beginners identify and avoid potential risks when selecting a cryptocurrency exchange.  The Role of Crypto Exchanges on the Digital Assets Market Cryptocurrency exchanges play a crucial role in…

What Is Grid Trading in Crypto?

Crypto grid trading has become a popular strategy because of its ability to help traders capitalize on market volatility. Grid trading means you can produce consistent profits by taking advantage of price differences in different markets or time frames. By establishing buy and sell orders at predetermined intervals, you can take advantage of these fluctuations in an automated way. This guide will explore the different aspects of grid trading and provide an overview of its benefits, challenges, and more. Through…

MORE ARTICLES

Tech

Introducing una Messenger: A Paradigm Shift in Blockchain Connectivity

The digital landscape is set for an unprecedented transformation with the introduction of una Messenger, the latest innovation from web3 development powerhouse Wemade. This platform represents an evolution of the "PAPYRUS Messenger," serving as the cornerstone of the ambitious "unagi" initiative, aimed at catalyzing the mass adoption of blockchain technology. The "Unbound Networking & Accelerating Growth Initiative" seeks to bridge the divides between diverse blockchain services and networks, heralding a new era of interconnectedness. A New Frontier in Blockchain Communication…

Bit2Me Champions WEMIX Token in Pioneering European Listing

Bit2Me, Spain's premier virtual asset exchange, has recently broadened the horizons for cryptocurrency enthusiasts by listing WEMIX, the cornerstone token of the WEMIX3.0 blockchain ecosystem. This marks a notable achievement as WEMIX's inaugural venture into the European market, emphasizing the token's role in facilitating a range of blockchain-based activities, from gaming transactions to decentralized finance (DeFi) applications. Launched with the intention to democratize access to WEMIX for the 450 million Spanish speakers around the globe, this strategic move aligns with…

CryptoVirally Expands with Fresh Crypto Marketing Offers and Cointelegraph Upgrades

In an exciting update for the cryptocurrency marketing landscape, CryptoVirally has announced a series of new entries and enhancements to its already comprehensive range of services. These updates, aimed at providing tailored marketing solutions for crypto projects, include new limited-time offers and expanded options for Cointelegraph publications. Limited Offers: A Game-Changer in Crypto Marketing  CryptoVirally's limited offers section presents an enticing opportunity for crypto projects to leverage high-impact marketing services at discounted rates. These offers, available for a limited period,…

Breaking Boundaries in Blockchain: WEMIX’s ‘una Wallet’ Sets New Standard for Multi-Chain Asset Management

The WEMIX Foundation has unveiled 'una Wallet,' a revolutionary digital wallet designed to offer unparalleled convenience and security in managing digital assets across various blockchain networks. The announcement, made on January 17, 2024, signifies a new era in the seamless integration of multiple blockchain protocols, including Arbitrum, Avalanche, BNB Smart Chain, Ethereum, Kroma, Optimism, Polygon, and WEMIX3.0. 'una Wallet' is more than just a digital wallet; it represents the culmination of WEMIX's innovative efforts in the blockchain space. It serves…

MORE ARTICLES