?>

The First Bitcoin ETF Is Already in Danger. Here’s Why

1.3 k views

The first US Bitcoin ETF – The ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF – may prove itself popular beyond sustainability. The fund is already approaching its limit on futures contracts holdings, as enforced by the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME).

Bitcoin ETF: Too Popular to Handle?

Last week, data from Bloomberg indicated that ProShares’ Bitcoin ETF was holding 1900 futures contracts dated for October. This was only 100 short of the 2000 futures contract limit that the CME imposed during an ETF’s first month.

Things don’t look much better going into the next month either. Bloomberg’s market data also showed 1400 November futures contracts held by ProShares. Monthly contract limits for November and beyond are as high as 5000, with additional agreements held under more significant trading limits. At the rate things are going, November is likely to approach its contract limit soon as well.

The ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (ticker: BITO) was the first and long-awaited Bitcoin ETF in the United States. After launching last week, the fund saw the second most successful opening day in New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) history. It raked $500 million in trades within an hour of opening and over $850 million by the end of the day. This number was only rivaled by a BlackRock carbon fund with pre-seed investments that raised its first-day volume.

ProShares will have to restart purchasing contracts dated for later months if monthly futures contract limits continue to break.

Nate Geraci – president of an advisory firm called “The ETF store” – explained why this is bad news for the futures market.

“The end result is the ETF will start taking on potentially significant tracking error versus the spot price of Bitcoin. The ETF is forced to obtain Bitcoin price exposure at higher and higher prices as it goes further out on the futures curve.”

Drawbacks of a Bitcoin Futures ETF

The SEC’s approval of a Bitcoin ETF has been a long-awaited and broadly welcomed development for Bitcoin. However, it has also seen substantial critics, and rightfully so. Generally speaking, Futures ETFs come with several disadvantages compared to their spot-based equivalents.

Detached Futures Market Prices

As Geraci points out, the futures markets will diverge further from Bitcoin’s spot price the later the contracts are dated.

As Bitcoin’s value is expected to grow over time, its future curve is upward sloping. This means that ProShares will be forced to purchase contracts at ever-increasing and detached prices compared to Bitcoin’s spot value. Therefore, ProShares risks exposure to Bitcoin at heavily inflated valuations.

Detached futures prices give wealthy investors accessible opportunities to arbitrage trade Bitcoin between spot and futures markets. This may apply whether futures curves are downward sloping in bear markets or upward sloping in bull markets.

Exorbitant Fees

Besides price tracking errors associated with the product, Futures ETFs also come packaged with multiple added fees for investors. These fees cut from profits they otherwise would have kept by investing in a spot-based ETF or actual BTC.

Raoul Pal – CEO of Global Macro Investor – voiced this concern before the first ETF’s launch.

“This vehicle means that the arbitrageurs take their slice, the ETF provider takes their slice, the lawyer who set up the fund takes their slice… the administrator, the auditor, everybody is taking a slice out of your pie.”

Paul contrasts this with simply buying hard Bitcoin, in which case only the exchange takes a small transaction fee. He also criticizes the concept of trading the cryptocurrency using paper, as Bitcoin’s core philosophy rests on the self-custody of coins.

Grayscale CEO Michael Sonnenshein also criticized the SEC’s preference of a Bitcoin Futures ETF over a spot ETF. “There are high costs that will make their way to investors…including the need to roll the contracts from one expiry to the next,” he told Marketwatch.

Grayscale is currently attempting to convert its current Bitcoin fund – the largest in the world – into a spot-based ETF. So far, they’ve had no luck.

Complications

Futures ETFs are undoubtedly complicated products. However, since they involve the price detachments and fees mentioned above, many clients may deem purchasing real bitcoin a more accessible alternative.

Ben Cruikshank – head of the Flourish Investing platform – explained to Market Watch that few firms were interested in Bitcoin Futures as imagined.

“The feedback that I’m getting is that a derivative is a less efficient form of ownership… are we going to recommend a complicated futures product that is more complicated than…opening a Coinbase account in 5 minutes?”

Cruikshank mentioned that the firms he had spoken to were “extremely skeptical” of a future product.

The Bright Side

That said, ProShares’ opening day success would still signal tremendous interest in the Futures-based ETF, despite its drawbacks. Moreover, the ETF may see some of its demand pressure alleviated as similar products flood into the market regarding its contract limit. Last Friday, Valkyrie launched the United States’ second Bitcoin ETF. Furthermore, VanEck’s ETF will soon begin trading and offer significantly lower fees than its current competitors.

Bloomberg’s senior ETF analyst Eric Balchunas also predicts that any negative outcome with BITO may spur the approval of a Bitcoin spot ETF. Grayscale’s ETF filing would likely be the first in line for this, allowing it to add to its existing 3.5% of Bitcoin supply.

Bitcoin coin symbol
Btc
Bitcoin
$62.547
price
red chart
decrease symbol0.84959%
price change
TRADE NOW

In the end, the ETF’s approval contributed to BTC’s price breaking all-time highs shortly after that. As a result, the markets ahead look remarkably bullish.

Previous

WMA: Bitcoin Sets New ATH at $66.9K Before Stabilizing at Around $60k

Next

Rand Paul: Cryptocurrency Could Reach World Reserve Status

Written by

476 posts

Andrew is a content writer with a passion for Bitcoin. He became familiar with Bitcoin back in 2013 but began diligently studying blockchain technology and its economic implications in 2017.

VIEW AUTHOR

More author posts

Sam Bankman-Fried May Now Contact FTX Employees — But There’s a Catch

Lawyers for FTX’s disgraced former boss, Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF), have reached an agreement with prosecutors allowing him to contact certain FTX employees. Besides certain restrictions, the 30-year-old may contact such parties through a host of new mediums. The New Rules Updated terms surrounding Bankman-Fried’s contact restrictions were sent to Lewis A. Kaplan – a judge for the Southern District of New York – in a letter on Monday.  Bankman-Fried’s lawyers said the updated conditions were a response to the government…

Uniswap Centralized? A16z Flexes Voting Power to Crush Governance Proposal 

The popular decentralized exchange, Uniswap, is having one of its latest governance proposals stonewalled by the crypto venture capital giant Andreesen Horowitz (a16z).  The ongoing proposal vote, which ends on February 10, is currently 38% weighed against the change – almost entirely due to the software investor. So Much for Decentralization The proposal, tabled by 0xPlasma Labs on February 2, would have Uniswap v3 deployed to BNB chain. To enable the deployment, the proposal chose to use Wormhole – an…

Silvergate Bank Hit With Fraud Probe Over FTX-Alameda Relationship

Crypto bank Silvergate is under investigation by the US Justice Department’s fraud unit for its dealings with FTX and its sister trading arm, Alameda Research.  The investigation is reviewing accounts concerning both businesses, which have been widely accused of engaging in a multi-billion dollar fraud using FTX customer funds.  What Happened at Silvergate? As reported by Bloomberg on Thursday, the La Jolla, California-based bank hasn’t been accused of any wrongdoing, and investigations could end without any charges being laid. However,…

Bitcoin Should be Banned in the United States: Charlie Munger

Berkshire Hathaway’s vice chairman, Charlie Munger, called for a ban on cryptocurrency in the United States on Monday, similar to the one in China.  In an op-ed published with the Wall Street Journal, Munger argued that Bitcoin isn’t a currency, commodity, or security, but simply a form of gambling “ with a nearly 100% edge for the house. As such, the enactment of a federal law should ban such things from happening. Munger cited the Chinese communist party’s ban on…

Oxford Student Jailed After Stealing $2.4 Million Through Crypto Scam

Wybo Wiersma – a 40-year-old Oxford University graduate – has been sentenced to four and a half years in prison after scamming over $2 million in crypto from unsuspecting victims. Following his arrest in 2019, the Netherlands extradited the Dutchman back to the United Kingdom (UK) in 2021. Following a five-year investigation by the South East Regional Organised Crime Unit (SEROCU), he pled guilty on January 26 to the Oxford Crown Court.  A Five-Year Investigation As reported by the Daily…

Like FTX, Celsius Used QuickBooks to Handle its Accounting

An independent examiner has revealed shocking details surrounding the inner workings of Celsius – a crypto lender that filed for bankruptcy in July 2022. The examiner claimed that Celsius did not operate by the business model that it presented to customers. He likened it to a Ponzi scheme, much like FTX – a company that happened to have used the same accounting software: QuickBooks.  The Truth About CEL Token Per a filing from examiner Shoba Pillay on Tuesday, Celsius had…

Publish your own article

Guest post article. Guaranteed publishing with just a few clicks

START PUBLISHING ADVERTISE WITH US

Browse categories

Explore trending topics in the crypto community right now.

Bitcoin

SEC Greenlights Multiple Bitcoin ETFs, Signaling Major Leap for Cryptocurrency Markets

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has made a landmark decision by approving 11 spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This move represents a significant moment in the cryptocurrency industry, marking a shift towards greater institutional adoption and accessibility for investors. The approved ETFs include products from major firms such as BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust, Grayscale Bitcoin Trust, ARK 21Shares Bitcoin ETF, Bitwise Bitcoin ETP Trust, WisdomTree Bitcoin Fund, Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Trust, VanEck Bitcoin Trust, Invesco Galaxy Bitcoin…

Bitcoin Should be Banned in the United States: Charlie Munger

Berkshire Hathaway’s vice chairman, Charlie Munger, called for a ban on cryptocurrency in the United States on Monday, similar to the one in China.  In an op-ed published with the Wall Street Journal, Munger argued that Bitcoin isn’t a currency, commodity, or security, but simply a form of gambling “ with a nearly 100% edge for the house. As such, the enactment of a federal law should ban such things from happening. Munger cited the Chinese communist party’s ban on…

Tesla’s BTC Positions Remained Unchanged in Q4 of 2022

According to a new earning report from automotive manufacturer Tesla, the company did not sell any of its BTC holdings in the fourth quarter of 2022. Amid speculations that the company had traded BTC during the testing bears, CEO Elon Musk revealed it was yet holding on to its BTC stash. Tesla Maintains Holdings After Initial Sell-Off In Q2 of 2022, Tesla opted to sell 75% of all its BTC. The car manufacturer received close to $950M in exchange. Notably,…

Here’s When Grayscale Debates the SEC in Court on its Bitcoin Spot ETF

The District of Columbia Court of Appeals has marked a date for when Grayscale and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may present oral arguments regarding the approval of a Bitcoin spot ETF.  Each side will present its case at 9:30 am ET on March 7, with the SEC arguing against the product, and Grayscale arguing in favor.  Grayscale VS SEC The court date – revealed in a court order filed on Monday according to CNBC – is much earlier…

MORE ARTICLES

Ethereum

Ethereum’s Zhejiang Staking Withdrawal Testnet for Shanghai is Live

At 15:00 UTC on Wednesday, the much-anticipated Zhejiang testnet for staking withdrawal went live on Ethereum’s Beacon chain. Zhejiang will enable the testing of the Ethereum Improvement Proposal (EIP) 4895 which allows for staking withdrawals. This is in preparation for the network’s next major update, the Shanghai hard fork slated to launch sometime in March. Users Can Make Simulated Withdrawals with Zhejiang In a tweet yesterday, DevOps engineer at Ethereum foundation Barnabas Busa gave details about the Zhejiang testnet slated…

Ethereum Devs Disagree Over Technical Tweak as Shanghai Upgrade Nears

Post-merge Ethereum users have been eagerly awaiting the commencement of the network’s next major upgrade, Shanghai. However, after over 3 months of prep time, it appears the Shanghai rollout isn’t going as smoothly as expected. What Exactly is the Shanghai Upgrade? In September last year, the much-publicized Ethereum Merge also known as the Ethereum 2.0 upgrade went live. Ethereum underwent some significant changes as its consensus mechanism transitioned from proof-of-work to a cost-efficient proof-of-stake system.  However, since the Beacon launch…

FTX Hacker Converts 50k Stolen ETH to BTC

Per a report from blockchain analysis firm Chainalysis, the attacker behind the Nov 11 FTX exploit, is converting the stolen ETH to Bitcoin. There were muted fears the seemingly inexperienced perpetrator could dump all its ETH holdings. On Sunday, the attacker dumped 50k ETH on-chain, with ETH's price dipping by almost 7%.  https://twitter.com/chainalysis/status/1594349583416840199?s=20&t=pgvQHeVytI20eKQ1ls9bxw Hacker Moves 50,000 ETH to New Address Over the past week, the perpetrator had been steadily swapping the cryptocurrencies they had carted off for Ether tokens. This…

Censorship Concerns: 51% of Ethereum Blocks Now OFAC Compliant

According to new data, over half of the blocks on the Ethereum network now reportedly comply with the US Treasury OFAC’s standards. This comes roughly a month after the platform’s monumental merge update. Phasing Out Tornado Cash The Office of Foreign Assets Control is the intelligence and enforcement agency of the US  Treasury Department. Indeed, the OFAC administers and enforces US  financial sanctions. A prime example of this is the recent, highly-publicized ban on crypto mixer Tornado Cash.  According to…

MORE ARTICLES

Trading

How to Leverage Arbitrage Opportunities in Crypto Markets

Cryptocurrency arbitrage has become an increasingly popular investment strategy as the crypto market grows and evolves. Arbitrage involves taking advantage of pricing discrepancies between markets or exchanges to profit.  Investors can leverage profit opportunities by understanding cryptocurrency arbitrage while managing associated risks. In this guide, we'll explore cryptocurrency arbitrage and how it works. A Bitcoin-related example will help us illustrate the concepts of this strategy. What is Arbitrage and How Does it Work in Crypto Markets Crypto arbitrage trading is…

The Different Types of Copy Trading in Crypto

Are you interested in trading cryptocurrencies but feel intimidated by the complexity of the process? Copy trading is a great way to get into crypto without needing to be an experienced trader. With copy trading, investors can benefit from the experience and knowledge of more experienced traders, allowing even beginners to succeed. How does copy trading work, and which tips do you need to know to succeed? In this article, we'll explore all aspects of copy trading in crypto. What…

How to Spot an Unsafe Crypto Exchange

Cryptocurrency exchanges have become increasingly popular as they provide a platform for people to buy and sell digital assets. Unfortunately, not all crypto exchanges are safe or reliable.  With the rise of cybercrime and fraud, you must learn to spot an unsafe crypto exchange before investing your money. This guide will help beginners identify and avoid potential risks when selecting a cryptocurrency exchange.  The Role of Crypto Exchanges on the Digital Assets Market Cryptocurrency exchanges play a crucial role in…

What Is Grid Trading in Crypto?

Crypto grid trading has become a popular strategy because of its ability to help traders capitalize on market volatility. Grid trading means you can produce consistent profits by taking advantage of price differences in different markets or time frames. By establishing buy and sell orders at predetermined intervals, you can take advantage of these fluctuations in an automated way. This guide will explore the different aspects of grid trading and provide an overview of its benefits, challenges, and more. Through…

MORE ARTICLES

Tech

Introducing una Messenger: A Paradigm Shift in Blockchain Connectivity

The digital landscape is set for an unprecedented transformation with the introduction of una Messenger, the latest innovation from web3 development powerhouse Wemade. This platform represents an evolution of the "PAPYRUS Messenger," serving as the cornerstone of the ambitious "unagi" initiative, aimed at catalyzing the mass adoption of blockchain technology. The "Unbound Networking & Accelerating Growth Initiative" seeks to bridge the divides between diverse blockchain services and networks, heralding a new era of interconnectedness. A New Frontier in Blockchain Communication…

Bit2Me Champions WEMIX Token in Pioneering European Listing

Bit2Me, Spain's premier virtual asset exchange, has recently broadened the horizons for cryptocurrency enthusiasts by listing WEMIX, the cornerstone token of the WEMIX3.0 blockchain ecosystem. This marks a notable achievement as WEMIX's inaugural venture into the European market, emphasizing the token's role in facilitating a range of blockchain-based activities, from gaming transactions to decentralized finance (DeFi) applications. Launched with the intention to democratize access to WEMIX for the 450 million Spanish speakers around the globe, this strategic move aligns with…

CryptoVirally Expands with Fresh Crypto Marketing Offers and Cointelegraph Upgrades

In an exciting update for the cryptocurrency marketing landscape, CryptoVirally has announced a series of new entries and enhancements to its already comprehensive range of services. These updates, aimed at providing tailored marketing solutions for crypto projects, include new limited-time offers and expanded options for Cointelegraph publications. Limited Offers: A Game-Changer in Crypto Marketing  CryptoVirally's limited offers section presents an enticing opportunity for crypto projects to leverage high-impact marketing services at discounted rates. These offers, available for a limited period,…

Breaking Boundaries in Blockchain: WEMIX’s ‘una Wallet’ Sets New Standard for Multi-Chain Asset Management

The WEMIX Foundation has unveiled 'una Wallet,' a revolutionary digital wallet designed to offer unparalleled convenience and security in managing digital assets across various blockchain networks. The announcement, made on January 17, 2024, signifies a new era in the seamless integration of multiple blockchain protocols, including Arbitrum, Avalanche, BNB Smart Chain, Ethereum, Kroma, Optimism, Polygon, and WEMIX3.0. 'una Wallet' is more than just a digital wallet; it represents the culmination of WEMIX's innovative efforts in the blockchain space. It serves…

MORE ARTICLES